A critique of the stanford experiment
The teacher would ask the experimenter to stop and end the test, but the latter would not let them and make the teacher continue the test. Zimbardo also strongly argues that the benefits gained about our understanding of human behavior and how we can improve society should out balance the distress caused by the study.
I lashed out with my stick and hit him on the chin although not very hard, and when I freed myself I became angry. Naval Research Review, 30, Catholic Priest Zimbardo invited a Catholic priest who had been a prison chaplain to evaluate how realistic our prison situation was.
Each prisoner had to be called only by his ID number and could only refer to himself and the other prisoners by number.
Criticism and response[ edit ] There has been controversy over both the ethics and scientific rigor of the Stanford prison experiment since nearly the beginning, and it has never been successfully replicated. Three guards worked shifts of eight hours each the other guards remained on call. The ringleaders of the prisoner rebellion were placed into solitary confinement. The guards may have been so sadistic because they did not feel what happened was down to them personally — it was a group norm. Zimbardo noted that, of more than 50 people who had observed the experiment, Maslach was the only one who questioned its morality. This site is about media, culture, technology, and randomness. Any characteristics of an experiment that let research participants guess how the experimenters expect or want them to behave are referred to as demand characteristics. For example, they had to refer to prisoners by number rather than by name. Studies must now undergo an extensive review by an institutional review board US or ethics committee UK before they are implemented. Zimbardo's goals[ edit ] The archived official website of the Stanford Prison Experiment describes the experiment goal as follows: We wanted to see what the psychological effects were of becoming a prisoner or prison guard. Prisoner Less than 36 hours into the experiment, Prisoner began suffering from acute emotional disturbance, disorganized thinking, uncontrollable crying, and rage. Some prisoners were forced to be naked as a method of degradation.
Therefore, the findings support the situational explanation of behavior rather than the dispositional one. The ringleaders of the prisoner rebellion were placed into solitary confinement.
based on 56 review